Prediction-market sports +EV: comparing Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig prices
What this guide covers
Kalshi and Polymarket are prediction markets, where people trade yes/no contracts and a contract's price is the market's probability for that outcome. Novig is an exchange: every market is an order book and prices are probabilities rather than American odds. ArchivePicks reads the public market data from all three and shows it next to the sportsbook lines for the same player and stat.
This guide explains how to put those prices on the same footing as sportsbook odds, how a +EV price is worked out, and where the idea stops being useful. It is arithmetic and reading advice for research, not a recommendation to trade or bet, and the examples use invented numbers.
What ArchivePicks shows from these markets
- Player props: for the NFL and the NBA, with each side's price converted to American odds. ArchivePicks shows each side at the price someone could actually buy it at, not at a midpoint.
- Game Lines: moneyline, spread and total. Kalshi and Polymarket cover the NFL, college football, the NBA and CS2 games they list; Novig covers the NFL, college football and NBA where its market can be matched to a game, refreshed in the background more slowly than props.
- Not shown: CS2 and college football player props from these markets, where Underdog is the only book.
Player props refresh every couple of minutes. Some game-line books refresh more slowly than props. A line older than 15 minutes is styled as possibly out of date, and any price may already have moved at the source. Each market has its own page: Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig.
Step 1: turn a price into a probability
A contract that pays 1 dollar if an outcome happens and trades at 62 cents implies a 62% chance, because paying 62 cents only breaks even if the outcome happens 62% of the time. In American odds that is -163. The same arithmetic runs in the other direction: a 41 cent price implies 41% and is +144. The odds converter and the implied probability calculator do this for you.
Yes and No are separate contracts, so their buy prices do not have to add up to exactly 100 cents. In the invented example the two sides total 103 cents. That gap is a real cost, and it is why a price shown for one side is not simply 100 minus the other.
Step 2: take out the margin
Every set of two-sided prices carries some margin, whether it is a sportsbook's vig or the gap between two buy prices. To compare sources fairly, scale each side by the total so the two add up to 100%. For the example above, 62 / 103 gives a no-vig chance of about 60.2% for Yes and 39.8% for No. This shares the margin across both sides in proportion; other methods give slightly different numbers. The no-vig calculator runs the same sum, and what a no-vig price is covers the reasoning.
A market that quotes only one side cannot have its margin removed this way, so it cannot be judged on this basis.
Step 3: compare one price with the rest of the market
ArchivePicks judges a price against the other books, never against itself. For each line it takes every book that prices that exact number, removes each book's margin, and averages the other books' chances. A price that pays more than that average implies has positive expected value: the profit per 1 staked if the other books' average were the true chance. A line needs at least three books before it can be judged, and the edge must be at least 1%.
An invented example. Two books post the same receiving-yards line. Book A has the over at -120 and the under at +100, and Book B has -125 and +105. Their no-vig chances for the over are 52.2% and 53.2%, an average of 52.7%. A third source, say an exchange, offers the over at +100. At +100 the payout is 2.00 in decimal terms, so the expected value is 52.7% x 2.00 - 1 = +5.4% of the stake. Its under at -125 pays 1.80, and the same sum gives -14.9%, so only the over would be flagged.
The +EV board lists the lines where this happens, ranked by the edge, and the methodology sets out the rules. What +EV means in player props has a longer walk-through.
What a +EV price does not tell you
- It is a comparison of prices. It uses no projections and says nothing about who will win. A +EV price can still lose, and a single result proves nothing.
- The market can be wrong together. If every book shades a number the same way, an average of them inherits the error.
- A gap is not automatically an opportunity. It can come from fees, spreads, thin trading, timing or different settlement rules rather than a real difference of opinion.
- The price may not be there when you look. Prediction-market prices move with every trade, and a displayed price may not hold for the size you want.
- It ignores the player. A price-based flag knows nothing about injuries or role. The hit rates, game log and matchup data on the player page are the context for that.
Rules also differ by venue. A sportsbook may void a prop if a player does not play, while a prediction market may settle by a fixed rule or an official stat source, and fees differ in how they are charged. Read the rules and the current fee schedule where you would use a market, and check what is available where you live: access to prediction markets and sportsbooks depends on location, and a stats site cannot tell you that.
A short routine for reading a prop
- Open a player on the NFL or NBA board and find the same stat and number across books with the line picker.
- Compare like with like: same player, same stat, same number, same side.
- Convert to one format and remove the margin from each source before comparing small gaps.
- Check each price's age, since a stale price can look like an edge.
- Then read the player's hit rates and game log, which are about the player rather than the price.
For more on reading these markets, see prediction market prices vs sportsbook odds and reading prediction market prop prices.
Frequently asked questions
Does ArchivePicks show Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig prices?
Yes. For NFL and NBA player props it shows prices from all three next to the sportsbook lines, converted to American odds, and each side is shown at the price someone could actually buy it at.
What does +EV mean on ArchivePicks?
A +EV price pays more than the other books' no-vig average at the same number. It is a comparison of prices only, so it says nothing about who will win and the price can still lose.
Why does a line sometimes have no +EV flag?
Either fewer than three books price that exact number, no price clears the 1% minimum edge, or one side is not quoted so the margin cannot be removed.
Does ArchivePicks tell me what to trade or bet?
No. It shows prices and hit rates side by side, takes no bets and does not hold money. Past results and price gaps do not guarantee anything.
Are prediction markets available everywhere?
No. Availability depends on where you live and on each venue's rules, and ArchivePicks cannot tell you what is open to you. Check before you use one.
Related
- Kalshi on ArchivePicks
- Polymarket on ArchivePicks
- Novig on ArchivePicks
- +EV board
- No-vig calculator
- Expected value calculator
- What +EV means in player props
- Prediction market prices vs sportsbook odds
- All guides
- Methodology
Trademarks and affiliation. Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig are trademarks of their respective owners and are named here only to say what ArchivePicks shows. ArchivePicks is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any of them, does not take bets or entries and has no betting or sign-up links. ArchivePicks does not take bets and does not tell you which side to take. For information only. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.